Lord Foster challenges UKGC stance on Pokémon cards and gambling law

Lord Foster challenges UKGC stance on Pokémon cards and gambling law

The dispute centres on whether collectible cards with a clear resale value should fall within the scope of the Gambling Act 2005.

Key takeaways

  • Lord Foster has questioned the Gambling Commission’s view that Pokémon card purchases fall outside UK gambling legislation.
  • He argues that some Pokémon cards have an objectively measurable cash value and are actively traded through retailers and online marketplaces.
  • The Gambling Commission says a secondary resale market does not automatically make trading card sales a form of gambling.
  • Acting chief executive Sarah Gardner warned that extending gambling regulation to trading cards could create unintended consequences for collectors, including young people.
  • The debate comes as Britain’s newly established Gambling Policy Commission reviews whether the Gambling Act 2005 remains fit for purpose.

Lord Foster, chair of Peers for Gambling Reform, has challenged the UK Gambling Commission’s position that Pokémon trading cards sit outside gambling legislation despite some cards carrying significant resale value. The disagreement highlights wider questions about how chance-based products should be treated under the Gambling Act 2005 as policymakers review whether the UK’s gambling framework requires reform.

UK.- Lord Foster, chair of Peers for Gambling Reform (PGR) in the UK House of Lords, has questioned whether Pokémon trading cards should fall under the definition of “money’s worth” under the Gambling Act 2005. He noted that some cards command substantial sums on the secondary market and can be readily exchanged for cash through retailers and online platforms.

The issue emerged in correspondence between Foster and the Gambling Commission during the past summer and recently discovered by the trading card news site Kanto Post. In a letter dated July 21, 2026, Foster wrote that it was “not immediately apparent” why Pokémon cards should not meet the legal definition when certain cards possess a measurable financial value and are regularly traded through commercial channels.

He argued that cards which “clearly possess an objectively ascertainable financial value and can readily be exchanged for cash” require a fuller explanation as to why they fall outside existing gambling legislation.

Foster contrasted the physical trading cards with digital items obtained through video game loot boxes, noting that Pokémon cards are bought and sold through “mainstream, legitimate and entirely lawful commercial channels”. While acknowledging that many consumers purchase the cards as collectibles or for gameplay purposes, he argued that regulators should also consider the way they are “bought, sold and valued”, as well as their popularity among younger people.

In his correspondence, Foster described the issue as a matter of wider public interest.

The Pokémon Trading Card Game (PTCG), which has experienced a surge in popularity in recent years. Increased visibility from content creators and the success of franchises such as Pokémon GO have helped drive demand for collectible cards. Last month, a collector in Woking sold a Pokémon card collection for £1.56m at auction, according to the BBC.

In his letter, Foster said Pokémon cards represented “a particularly good case to pursue because there is clear evidence that cash trading does take place”.

The Gambling Commission, however, rejected the suggestion that a secondary resale market automatically transforms the purchase of trading cards into a gambling activity. Responding on August 11, acting chief executive Sarah Gardner wrote: “In our view, the fact that Pokémon cards may subsequently be traded or sold on a secondary market does not, of itself, mean that their sale constitutes gambling.”

Gardner said the Gambling Act had not been intended to regulate trading cards or football sticker collections simply because their purchase involves an element of chance. She added that the regulator remains willing to examine products that may fall within the legal definition of gambling, particularly where gambling-like features are integrated into what would otherwise be a retail experience, but stated that the regulator is “not currently undertaking activity in relation to the purchase or trading of collectable cards or stickers”.

She also stressed that while the regulator has a duty to protect children and vulnerable people from gambling-related harm, it must operate within the legal framework established by parliament. Any changes to the definition of gambling, or to the Commission’s powers, would be a matter for lawmakers rather than the regulator.

Foster has long advocated greater scrutiny of gambling-style mechanics in games and digital entertainment.

FAQs

Why has Lord Foster questioned the status of Pokémon cards under UK law?

Lord Foster argues that some Pokémon cards have a clear and measurable financial value and can be readily exchanged for cash. He believes this raises questions about why they do not meet the Gambling Act’s definition of “money’s worth”.

What is the Gambling Commission’s view on Pokémon cards?

The Gambling Commission says that the existence of a secondary market does not make the sale of Pokémon cards a gambling activity. It maintains that trading cards were not intended to be regulated as gambling products under current legislation.

Could Pokémon cards become regulated as gambling products in the UK?

The Commission says any change to the legal definition of gambling would be a matter for parliament rather than the regulator. No current activity is underway relating to the purchase or trading of collectible cards or stickers.

How does this debate relate to loot boxes and similar products?

Lord Foster has linked Pokémon cards to broader discussions about gambling-like mechanics. The issue also overlaps with European debates around paid variable reward systems, including loot boxes, wheels of fortune and collectible card packs.

In this article:
Gambling Commission gambling legislation gambling regulation