CJEU declines to rule on Malta’s Bill 55 gambling dispute

CJEU declines to rule on Malta’s Bill 55 gambling dispute

The decision leaves uncertainty over the law’s compatibility with EU principles as cross-border gambling claims continue.

Key takeaways

  • The CJEU declined to rule on whether Malta’s Bill 55 is compatible with EU law.
  • The court returned the case to Austria, finding that the legality of Bill 55 was not necessary to resolve the professional negligence dispute before it.
  • Bill 55 was introduced to prevent enforcement in Malta of certain gambling-related judgments from other EU countries.
  • The legislation has become a focal point in claims by Austrian players seeking to recover losses from Malta-licensed gambling operators.
  • The absence of a substantive CJEU ruling means legal uncertainty surrounding Bill 55 is likely to continue across Europe.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has declined to determine whether Malta’s Bill 55 complies with EU law, leaving one of Europe’s most closely watched gambling legal disputes unresolved. The case arose from litigation linked to Austrian players seeking to recover losses from Malta-licensed operators, but the court concluded that assessing the law’s legality was unnecessary for the specific dispute before it. As a result, wider questions over the status of Bill 55 under European law remain unanswered.

Luxembourg.- The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has declined to issue a definitive ruling on whether Malta’s controversial Bill 55 complies with European Union law. The decision leaves a significant dispute for cross-border gambling claims unresolved.

The case relates to a series of legal battles that have been unfolding for several years over losses incurred by German and Austrian players on gambling websites licensed in Malta but operating outside domestic regulated gambling frameworks. Malta introduced Bill 55 in 2023 through amendments to its Gambling Act in an attempt to shield Malta-licensed gambling operators from the enforcement of court judgments originating in other EU countries. That quickly drew criticism from regulators and player advocates across Europe.

The Maltese government has argued that the law is consistent with the EU’s principles of free movement and freedom to provide services, maintaining that gambling operators licensed in Malta should not face barriers when operating across the European single market.

The issue has been particularly contentious in Austria, where increasing numbers of players have sought to recover gambling losses from Malta-based operators that were not licensed under Austria’s domestic regime. One of the organisations involved in supporting such claims has been Spielerschutz Sigma, which has helped finance legal actions brought by Austrian players seeking compensation.

Following the introduction of Bill 55, it partnered with an Austrian legal practice to obtain an assessment of the new legislation’s compatibility with EU law. According to the organisation, the opinion concluded that Bill 55 conflicted with established European legal principles and therefore should not be applicable in Maltese courts.

The dispute took a further turn when Spielerschutz Sigma filed a claim against the law firm that provided the original legal opinion, seeking compensation on the basis of alleged professional negligence. The Commercial Court of Vienna later referred the matter to the CJEU in 2024, asking Europe’s highest court to clarify whether Malta’s legislation was compatible with European law.

However, while the CJEU has previously omitted negative opinions on Bill 55, if not binding rulings, in this case it opted to return the matter to the Austrian court without addressing that question as it concluded that determining the legality of Bill 55 was not necessary for resolving the professional negligence dispute before the Vienna court.

While the decision removes the issue from the immediate proceedings in Vienna, it does not settle the broader legal debate surrounding Malta’s legislation. Claims against Malta-licensed operators continue to be pursued elsewhere in Europe, including in Germany, where players are also seeking to recover gambling losses through the courts.

FAQs

What is Malta’s Bill 55?

Bill 55 is a 2023 amendment to Malta’s Gambling Act designed to protect Malta-licensed gambling operators from the enforcement of certain court judgments issued in other EU countries.

Why did the CJEU not rule on Bill 55?

The court concluded that deciding whether Bill 55 complies with EU law was not necessary to resolve the professional negligence case referred to it by the Commercial Court of Vienna.

Why is Bill 55 controversial?

Critics argue that the law prevents the enforcement of judgments against Malta-licensed operators in other EU jurisdictions, while supporters maintain it is consistent with EU principles relating to free movement and the freedom to provide services.

Does the CJEU decision settle the legality of Bill 55?

No. The court did not issue a substantive ruling on the law’s compatibility with EU law, meaning the broader legal debate and related litigation are expected to continue.

Which countries are seeing gambling claims linked to Bill 55?

The dispute has been particularly prominent in Austria, where players have sought to recover gambling losses from Malta-licensed operators. Similar claims are also continuing in Germany.

In this article:
Gambling gambling legislation gambling regulation